Wagon Rolls
2 for $6.95 · 4 for $12.95
Handmade egg rolls stuffed with slow-smoked brisket and premium Wisconsin cheddar, served with house-made Carolina Gold BBQ sauce.
The Monticello food menu
Find your Pink Heifer favorite.
USDA Prime brisket smoked for 12 to 14 hours. Brisket and cheddar Wagon Rolls. Creamy mac and cheese. Come hungry for the Monticello smokehouse menu.
Pink Heifer Monticello
Appetizers
Cheese Curds
$9.95
A half pound of premium Wisconsin cheese curds with Alabama white BBQ sauce.
Bella Flats
$9.95
A half pound of deep-fried portabella mushroom slices with house-made Alabama white BBQ sauce.
Onion Rings
$6.95
A half pound of breaded, thick-cut onion rings.
Pink Heifer Monticello
Salads
Southwest Salad
$15.95
Choice of pork or chicken on romaine with tomatoes, onions, black beans, corn and shredded cheddar. Southwest ranch. Substitute carved brisket +$3 or burnt ends +$4.
Caesar Salad
$9.95
Add pulled chicken or pork +$4, brisket +$6 or burnt ends +$7.
Pink Heifer Monticello
Comfort Food
Prices are for each complete dish. Plain Mac n’ Cheese does not include meat.
Mac n’ Cheese
$7.00
Made with Monterey Jack and Wisconsin cheddar.
Pork Mac or Chicken Mac
$10.95
House-made Mac n’ Cheese topped with your choice of pulled smoked chicken or pulled pork.
Brisket Mac
$12.95
Mac n’ Cheese topped with brisket.
Burnt Ends Mac
$13.95
House-made Mac n’ Cheese topped with double-smoked brisket burnt ends.
Pink Heifer Monticello
Smokehouse Platters
Served with cornbread, pickles and two sides. Substitute a small dinner salad for one side +$2.
Brisket Burnt Ends
$24.95
Ten ounces of cubed USDA Prime brisket, double-smoked with caramelized BBQ sauce.
Carved Brisket
$22.95
Ten ounces of USDA Prime brisket smoked for 12 to 14 hours and carved to order.
Smoked ½ Chicken Platter
$15.95
Hickory and cherry wood smoked chicken.
Pulled Chicken
$16.95
A half pound of pulled smoked chicken.
Pulled Pork
$15.95
A half pound of premium pork smoked over cherry and hickory wood.
Pink Heifer Monticello
Sandwiches
Swap seasoned potato wedges for Mac n’ Cheese, cowboy beans, coleslaw, elotes, potato pancakes or a small dinner salad for an additional $2.
Brisket Burnt Ends
$17.95
Savory burnt ends on a toasted brioche bun.
Carved Brisket
$16.95
Brisket carved to order on a toasted brioche bun.
Pulled Pork
$11.95
Cherry- and hickory-smoked pork.
Chicken Sandwich
$7
Cherry and hickory smoked chicken on a toasted brioche bun, with pickles and seasoned potato wedges.
C.K. Smasher
$13.95
Two smashed patties of brisket, short rib, and chuck with crispy bacon, smoked jalapeño Alabama BBQ cream cheese, and caramelized onions on toasted brioche. Served with seasoned potato wedges.
Pink Heifer Monticello
Lil’ Sheriff’s Menu
For kids 12 and under. Every meal includes potato wedges, applesauce, fruit snacks and a drink.
Mac n’ Cheese
$5
Chicken Tenders · 2 pieces
$5
Smoked Chicken Legs · 3 pieces
$5
St. Louis Ribs · 3 pieces
$5
Pink Heifer Monticello
Family Platters
Appetizers: onion rings, cheese curds, four Wagon Rolls or Bella Flats. Large sides: coleslaw, Mac n’ Cheese, cowboy beans, elotes or potato pancakes.
Small Family Platter · Feeds 4–5
$84.95
Half slab ribs; half pound each of brisket, pulled pork and pulled chicken; wedges; four cornbread; one appetizer and two large sides. Add half pound burnt ends +$15.
Large Family Platter · Feeds 8–10
$159.95
Full slab ribs; one pound each of brisket, pulled pork and pulled chicken; wedges; eight cornbread; two appetizers and four large sides. Add one pound burnt ends +$30.
Pink Heifer Monticello
Smoked Prime Rib
Last Saturday of every month beginning at 4 PM. Served with two sides, dinner salad and a roll.
Petite · 8–10 ounces
$29.95
Traditional · 14–16 ounces
$39.95
Pink Heifer Monticello
Sides
Potato Pancakes · 3 pieces
$6
With sour cream and applesauce.
Coleslaw
$6
Cowboy Beans
$6
Smoked four-bean and brisket Southern favorite.
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$6
Seasoned Potato Wedges
$4.50
Mac n’ Cheese
$7.00
Made with Monterey Jack and Wisconsin cheddar.
Cornbread · 3 pieces
$4.50
Pink Heifer Monticello
Desserts
Old-Fashioned Carrot Cake
$6.95
Chocolate Lava Cake
$5.95
7 Deadly Sins Chocolate Cake
$5.95
Pink Heifer Monticello
Smokehouse by the Pound
Brisket by the Pound
$32.95
Pulled Chicken · 1 pound
$21.95
Pink Heifer Monticello
Friday Fish Fry
Available Fridays at Pink Heifer in Monticello.
Friday Cod Fish Fry
$15.95
Fried cod served with potato wedges, coleslaw, a roll, tartar sauce, and lemon.
Many menu favorites available for takeout
Take the SmokeShow home.
Monticello restaurant menu. Online pickup prices and availability may differ; the ordering page shows your pickup total. For allergies or dietary questions, please speak with the Pink Heifer team before ordering.
Saloon drinks menu